Keegan Caps Its Season With Hilarious New Production

If you’re looking for a refreshing recharge from the daily DC delirium, run to the Keegan Theatre to catch their raucous production of The Play That Goes Wrong. If the Zucker Brothers and Jim Abrahams were to ever have moved on from the movies Airplane! and The Naked Gun and start making laugh-a-minute Broadway comedies, The Play That Goes Wrong could be the kind of comedy they just might make. The Keegan’s production is packed with a cacophony of calamities, making the play the most fun you’ll have in a theatre this summer.

Laughs From London Lead To DC

The Play That Goes Wrong arrived at the Keegan with an impressive pedigree. Written by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer, and Henry Shields of London’s Mischief Theatre, the show opened to rave reviews and went on to win the Olivier Award in 2015 for Best New Comedy. The Play That Goes Wrong ranks among the best stage comedies from London’s theatre scene, following in the footsteps of previous Olivier winners such as Noises Off, Art, The 39 Steps, and Educating Rita, while blazing its own trail from London’s West End. Originating as a fringe production in London, it expanded into a worldwide hit, proving its mettle from intimate black-box theaters to the bright lights of Broadway.

In an interview with DC Theater Arts ahead of the production’s opening, director Michael Innocenti described the play as “a masterwork of physical comedy, precise timing, and theatrical chaos.” Innocenti noted that while the premise is deceptively simple, an amateur theater company attempting to perform a 1920s murder mystery in which everything that can go wrong does, the comedy depends on extraordinary precision behind the scenes. “Comedy requires everything to go right in order to revel in everything going wrong,” Innocenti explained, emphasizing both the technical challenges facing the cast and creative team and the show’s promise of “a night of pure laughter” for audiences.

Disaster Strikes, Laughter Ensues

From the moment a cast member of the play-within-a-play steps forward to address the audience, pulling everyone directly into the performance, the production seizes our attention. The play never relinquishes its grip, from humorously shattering the audience’s fourth wall with witty references to other prestigious DC theatres, to shattering the inner fourth wall between the fictional actors and their stage crew. Within this frantic framework, “mistakes” and the actors’ panicky, improvised attempts at damage control snowball, creating increasingly slapstick results. The comedy’s split-second timing delivers side-splitting laughter as each on-stage disaster spirals into an even funnier fiasco. The set itself behaves like another actor entirely, triggering its own series of mini-disasters where props fail and fall with impeccable comedic timing.

The actors portraying the stage crew deepen the chaos, their desperate attempts to salvage the show only adding to the calamity. They interact with the broken environment not just as stagehands, but as participants in the unfolding disaster, blurring the line between the play and the meta-narrative. Ultimately, this layering of reality and fiction both entertains and includes the audience, creating a shared space where actors on the stage and people in their seats are all on the same thespian carnival ride. The play is another superb production that showcases the Keegan’s deftness in presenting theatrical comedies, from introspective humor such as this past spring’s staging of The Minutes, to farcical fun as seen in the Keegan’s production of Noises Off. The Play That Goes Wrong combines physical comedy and escalating disasters into a tightly orchestrated theatrical experience. 

From Enthralling to Entertaining, The Keegan Theatre Always Delivers

Given the Keegan’s reputation for engaging ensemble performances, from comedy to drama, it’s no surprise that the cast and crew once again make a complex production seem effortlessly breezy. In comedy, timing is everything. The Play That Goes Wrong delivers a relentless barrage of jokes and gags, requiring actors and stage crew to hit their marks with precision, and the Keegan company nails every mark, giving the audience the gift of cathartic comedy. Laughter is the best medicine, and the Keegan Theatre consistently proves itself a reliable pharmacist.

---

Keegan’s staging marks the finale of the theater’s 29th season, bringing the internationally acclaimed farce to Dupont Circle audiences for a summer run. The production features an ensemble cast including Darren Badley, Rebecca Ballinger, Jimmy Bartlebaugh, Jared H. Graham, Leah Packer, Matthew Pauli, Jackson Saunders, and Martina Schabron, and is directed by Michael Innocenti.

The Play That Goes Wrong is showing at The Keegan Theatre through July 19th, 2026. For tickets and information, visit: https://keegantheatre.com/portfolio/the-play-that-goes-wrong/ 

Playwrights: Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer, and Henry Shields

Director: Michael Innocenti

Runtime: 2 hours including one 15-minute intermission